11.21.09
LIFESTYLE

Does Being Raised Bilingual Increase Your Child's Chance of Stuttering?

istockphoto.com

Are you all for teaching your child both English and Español? While there are many obvious benefits to speaking more than one language, parents should take note: recent findings show that children who are bilingual before the age of five are more likely to stutter than those who only speak one language before this age. Not only that, but bilingual tots also have a harder time correcting their speech down the line.

The study, published in the Archives of Disease in Childhood, explains how children who learned both languages before starting school had a 25% chance of losing their impediment while those who spoke only one language had a 55% chance of recovering. Although researchers say school performance was not affected, they suggest holding off on teaching your child a second language to reduce their risk.

According to The Stuttering Foundation at least half a million bilingual people in the United States stutter. Take note if your child mixes vocabulary from both languages (so no Spanglish with the little one), has difficulties finding the right words to express herself or has a harder time than other kids her age in creating grammatically complex sentences.

Visit stutteringhelp.org for more info on risk factors and ways to help correct your child’s speech impediment.

8 Comments
In response to "Nana's" statement. I have no child/children. I speak from experience. Children should learn as many languages as possible. From 0 to 6 years of age they can probably learn up to 10 languages. My point was that "Immersion" is less costly and actually works. Bi-lingual education is VERY costly. I also take great exception that my tax dollars are used for translation on every government/county/city document. The parents I worked with never wanted to learn the language and expected that one speak Spanish to them. How do you deal with the chil'd life. Most of them had their child doing everything an adult and parent should do. The children were very burdened. This is not only arrogant but absured. If you live in this country, speak English. Thanks For letting me have my say, TD :)
I am now 30 years old. As a child my mother was bilingual in Spanish and English. She figured that we (3 siblings) would absorb the English language in school, with TV, and the environment around us. So at home we mainly spoke Spanish during the first few years of our lives, especially at Abuelita's house. My mom was right by the time we entered pre-school we understood both languages. Yes, we did attend a bilingual school and had great teachers. My Mother was actively involved in our education and always had high expectation in everything we did. But she learned that each of her children had different capabilities. Those of us who excelled, better things were expected and those who had a bit of struggles, she worked accordingly with. I can't thank my mother, grandparents and teachers enough for teaching me our beautiful Spanish language. Whenever I go to Latin American countries people hear me speak Spanish, they know I'm from the US and they expect me to speak poorly. Yet they are amazed, they tell me that they are impressed with my Spanish. The same happens here. I am Mexican and Puerto Rican and because I really don't have either country’s accent they ask me "where are your roots from?” they tell me “hablas el español muy bien”. And every time I hear that it makes me so proud of my roots. It reminds me how important it is to be poised, stand up straight and proud of our beautiful culture. How can you not give your child that? Now that I am expecting my first child I hope that my husband and I can raise him/her with the same dignity and respect for our native tongue that I was raised with. It can be done!
In response to TD's comment, Im not sure what state/school district you or your children belong to but I have been a witness of parents whom are very and I mean VERY involved in their child's life. They attend EVERY school event and are very attentive to their child's education. These are parents who speak very little English. I currently have four students who are GT, which shows how parent support evidently makes a difference in a child's life. Readers please realize the valuable gift it will be for your child to be bilingual and the benefits it will bring to him/her when she grows up. My fiancee reminds his mom all the time of the disservice she did to him for not teaching him/exposing Spanish to him as he grew up. The sooner, the easier it''ll be for your child to gain the language :)
This statement is invalid, coming from a familiar background. Im currently a bilingual teacher and if a parent(s) speak/expose their kids to more than one language as they're being raised, it will by not affect their speech. A child's brain is like a sponge, the more you feed it, the more it absorbs. Such cases mentioned could've been present to children that were raised bilingual, however, other circumstances must've taken place at the same time; information that was not fully given to us as readers. Please do not be discouraged from raising your kids with two languages and please consider having your kids be part of a strong bilingual program...get informed! :)
I grew up bi-lingual. I am fluent in two languages and okay in one other. I did not experience stuttering however, I found that my youngest sibling did. I base this on lack of motherly attention, as being from a large family the youngest always gets the attention from his siblings and not the mother. One important reason why people should limit the number of children they have. I am Against bi-lingual education and I support immersion. I have had experience in this field. The costfor bi-lingual education is ludicrous. Furthermore, the parents lacks in participation, assimilation, and acclamation to our customs and cultures here. I am not saying loose you heritage..just incorporate ours since you are living in this country. I found in my home visits that Mexican parents would NOT bother to learn the language and therefore lacked in participating in their children's all around upbrining. No participation in PTA, teachers had to hire interpreters, no help to their children with homework...and the list goes on and on! Thanks for letting me have my say. TD :)
Readers will want to know that the Stuttering Foundation also maintains a Spanish Web site, www.tartamudez.org. Many of their materials are in Spanish and English including DVDs. Their Web sites, www.tartamudez.org and www.stutteringhelp.org, have brochures and books that are available for free downloading and several DVDs are free video-streaming. These materials provide effective ways for preschoolers, elementary children, teenagers, and adults to deal with stuttering.
As a person who grew up bilingual and a linguist, I find this article very surprising. I think that these types of articles and stories, instead of promoting bilingualism make people scared of it. It is a fact that the younger one is, the easier it is to learn a second or third language. Stuttering is a speech disorder and has nothing to do with how the brain distinguishes between and process two or more languages. It is perfectly normal for children to mix languages, which is called code-switching-not spanglish when they are learning to speak. Even monolingual children stutter and mix up their speech- it is all part of the language learning process. In sum, for those of you who read this- please don't stop speaking your home language with your child. You will regret it in the long run!! Speaking to your children in the second language is one of the most precious and important gifts you can give him/her.
i thank u for your words of wisdom. i agree w/u 110 %!

SUBSCRIBE NOW AND SAVE 66%

Limachips built this